Charter Schools: Hope or Hype? by Jack Buckley

By Jack Buckley

During the last a number of years, privately run, publicly funded constitution faculties were bought to the yank public as an schooling replacement promising higher pupil fulfillment, better dad or mum pride, and extra shiny university groups. yet are constitution faculties providing on their promise? Or are they only hype as critics contend, a expensive scan that's bleeding tax money from public faculties? during this booklet, Jack Buckley and Mark Schneider take on those questions on one of many thorniest coverage reforms within the state this present day. utilizing an incredibly rigorous study method, the authors examine constitution colleges in Washington, D.C., rigorously studying tuition information going again greater than a decade, reading rankings of interviews with mom and dad, scholars, and academics, and meticulously measuring how constitution colleges practice in comparison to conventional public colleges. Their conclusions are sobering. Buckley and Schneider convey that charter-school scholars should not outperforming scholars in conventional public colleges, that the standard of charter-school schooling varies broadly from college to college, and that father or mother enthusiasm for constitution colleges starts off out powerful yet fades over the years. they usually argue that whereas constitution colleges could meet the main simple try out of sound public policy--they do no harm--the proof indicates all of them too frequently fall in need of advocates' claims. With the way forward for constitution schools--and possibly public schooling as a whole--hanging within the stability, this e-book helps the case for containing constitution faculties extra liable and brings us significantly closer to resolving this contentious debate.

Show description

Read or Download Charter Schools: Hope or Hype? PDF

Best public affairs books

Self-Organizing Federalism: Collaborative Mechanisms to Mitigate Institutional Collective Action Dilemmas

This ebook investigates the self-organizing responses of governments and pursuits to the institutional collective motion (ICA) dilemmas of specific predicament to scholars of federalism, city governance, and nearby administration of average assets. ICA dilemmas come up in fragmented platforms each time judgements by way of one autonomous formal authority don't ponder bills or advantages imposed on others.

State and Local Government Statistics at a Crossroads

Because the early days of the state, the government has accumulated details at the sales, bills, and different beneficial properties of kingdom and native jurisdictions and their operations. this day, those info are amassed essentially by way of the Governments department of the U. S. Census Bureau, which has carried out a census of governments each five years seeing that 1957.

International Conflict Management: An Introduction

This new textbook offers scholars with an obtainable review of the common sense, evolution, software and results of the 5 significant techniques of the turning out to be box of overseas clash administration: conventional peacekeeping peace enforcement and help operations negotiation and bargaining mediation adjudication.

Best Practices for Transportation Agency Use of Social Media

Well timed updates, elevated citizen engagement, and greater advertising are only some of the purposes transportation firms have already began to undertake social media networking instruments. most sensible Practices for Transportation organization Use of Social Media bargains real-world recommendation for making plans and imposing social media from major govt practitioners, educational researchers, and specialists.

Additional resources for Charter Schools: Hope or Hype?

Example text

The Board of Education, on the other hand, is often characterized as hostile. Hill and colleagues suggest that the charter-granting behavior of the Board of Education highlights its vulnerability to local political forces (Hill et al. 2001). A later study by Henig and MacDonald (2002) offers some corroborating evidence. The authors demonstrate that the schools chartered by the Board of Education were located in wards with higher voter turnout and a higher concentration of African Americans. In contrast, the Public Charter School Board was found to be focused on pragmatic considerations, such as operational and fiscal viability (also see Hassel and Batdorff 2004 on the greater susceptibility of school districts to political factors).

Per-student payments for students in charter schools total around $10,000, but in the recently approved federally supported program, vouchers are set at only $7,500. The second dimension, choice, is also central to our study, for two reasons. First, as noted above, choice by itself should improve the match between what parents and students want and what they get from their schools. This in turn should improve parent and student satisfaction with their schools. Second, choice is intimately linked to competition.

The central impetus for the adoption of choice-based educational reforms in the District of Columbia can be traced to the fiscal crisis of 1995, when the District’s schools were faced with mounting problems stemming from fiscal mismanagement and administrative corruption. Facing a budget deficit of $722 million, the city was taken over by the Control Board, formally known as the Fiscal Responsibility and Management Assistance Authority. The Control Board in turn took over the schools, appointing an emergency board of trustees.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.87 of 5 – based on 7 votes